To homepage
4.6/5
TrustPilot

Best Nasal polyp surgery doctors in Turkey: TOP 53 doctors

Compare top Nasal polyp surgery doctors and prices in Turkey. Find your best match here.

Get quotes from 3 top Nasal polyp surgery specialists in Turkey

We'll hand-pick the best doctors based on your needs and budget.

Meet the experts behind this page

Top doctors

53

Turkey

Reviews

14,000+

From real patients

Choose the country with the best prices for doctors' services

Compare prices for Nasal polyp surgery across top countries

Tap a country to view top doctors and prices

Ukraine
Turkey
Mexico
Thailand
Czech Republic
Spain
$1,300 - $2,000
$2,000 - $3,200
$2,200 - $4,200
$2,200 - $4,000
$2,800 - $4,800
$2,800 - $4,200
$0
$1,000
$2,000
$3,000
$4,000
$5,000

What Bookimed patients actually pay for Nasal polyp surgery in Turkey

Most popular range

$2K

$3K

$4K

$6K+

$8K+

$800 – $3,000

Most patients pay within this range

The exact cost depends on the chosen doctor, technique, areas treated, and your individual needs.

Get a precise quote for your case.

Get free personalized treatment plans and choose the best option. No commitment · No payments for our services

Show first:

10 people have requested a quote last month

Selman Sarica

  • 5 Excellent 2 reviews
  • 20 years of experience
  • 1000+ treatments performed
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Assoc. Prof. Selman Sarica specializes in endoscopic sinus surgery, including nasal polyp removal, at Hisar Hospital Intercontinental.

    • Over 20 years of experience of experience in otorhinolaryngology
    • Expert in functional nasal surgeries like septoplasty and concha surgery
    • Associate Professor with extensive academic background
  • Read more
Package price from$2,500

Mehmet Emre Ustundag

  • 36 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Prof. Dr. Mehmet Emre Ustundag specializes in nasal polyp surgery at Anadolu Medical Center, with decades of expertise in rhinology.

    • Professor of Otorhinolaryngology with over 30 years of experience
    • Trained in rhinology at University of Regensburg, Germany
    • Member of the German Society of Otorhinolaryngology
    • Published 47 international articles with 788 citations
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Serkan Orhan

  • 23 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr. Orhan specializes in nasal polyp surgery with advanced training from top European hospitals, including Radboud University and Royal National ENT Hospital

    • Trained in otolaryngology with specialization completed in 2004
    • Advanced rhinoplasty and facial plastic surgery skills
    • International expertise from Netherlands and UK institutions
    • Experience in both civilian and military medical settings
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Dogukan Aydenizoz

  • 10 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Antalya
  • Dr. Aydenizoz specializes in advanced ENT care at Medical Park Antalya Hospital Complex, focusing on nasal polyp surgery with precision and patient-centered care.

    • Completed ENT specialty training at Antalya Training and Research Hospital
    • Member of the Turkish Facial Plastic Surgery Association
    • Offers endoscopic sinus surgery for nasal polyps
    • Combines functional health with natural-looking aesthetic results
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Burak Özkan

  • 5 Excellent 1 review
  • 17 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Associate Professor at Medipol Acibadem District Hospital with international fellowships in plastic and reconstructive surgery.

    • Specialized in plastic, reconstructive, and aesthetic surgery since 2015
    • Active member of EURAPS and other prestigious surgical societies
    • Trained at leading institutions in Japan, Belgium, and South Korea
    • Executive committee member of International Society of Burn Injuries
    • Performs nasal polyp surgeries with a focus on aesthetic outcomes
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Yasin Kulaksiz

  • 9 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Specialized in ENT surgeries including advanced rhinoplasty techniques – Dr. Kulaksiz focuses on precise nasal procedures at Medipol Acibadem District Hospital.

    • PhD in Ear, Nose, and Throat (ENT) from Bezmialem Vakıf University
    • Expertise in surgical techniques and postoperative management
    • Skilled in patient assessment and personalized care plans
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Dr Arzu Öz

  • 14 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr Arzu Öz brings over 14 years of experience of ENT experience, specializing in nasal polyp surgery at CE International Hospital.

    • Specialized in ENT and Head, Neck Surgery since 1995
    • Worked at top hospitals including Acibadem Altunizade and Medient ENT Center
    • Performs both diagnostic and surgical treatments for nasal conditions
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Ziya Ilgin

  • Leading doctor for Nasal polyp surgery
  • 30 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Specializes in Functional Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (FESS) for nasal polyps – Dr. Ilgin brings precision to sinus and nasal procedures at Büyük Anadolu Hospitals.

    • 30 years of experience of ENT experience
    • Expert in advanced rhinology and sleep apnea surgeries
    • Trained at Marmara University, one of Turkey's leading medical schools
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Celil Göçer

  • 30 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Ankara
  • Prof. Dr. Celil Göçer brings over 30 years of experience of ENT expertise, with advanced training at the House Ear Institute in Los Angeles.

    • Specializes in complex nasal polyp and sinus conditions
    • Published 30+ scientific articles on ENT topics
    • Recognized for excellence in clinical practice and surgical training
    • Professor at Lokman Hekim Health Group since 2011
    • Presented groundbreaking studies at international conferences
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Celil Göçer

  • 5 Excellent 2 reviews
  • 30 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Prof. Dr. Celil Göçer is a distinguished ENT specialist with advanced training at the House Ear Institute in Los Angeles, focusing on complex nasal and sinus conditions.

    • Over 30 scientific articles published on ENT topics, including sinus conditions
    • Specializes in rhinological conditions like sinusitis and mucosal pathologies
    • Recognized for excellence in clinical practice and surgical training
    • Professor at Lokman Hekim Health Group since 2011
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Ozgur Erdem

  • Leading doctor for Nasal polyp surgery
  • 11 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Antalya
  • Clinic:
    4.9
    Soraca Med
  • Performed over 2,000 functional and aesthetic nasal surgeries – Dr. Erdem specializes in nasal procedures at his private clinic in Antalya.

    • Completed doctoral research on OSAS and snoring surgery
    • Attended numerous national and international congresses as a speaker
    • Focuses on both functional and aesthetic nasal surgery
    • Works at his private clinic, ERD Clinic Health Services Ltd
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Yasemin Ongun

  • 21 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Specializing in nasal polyp surgery, Dr. Yasemin Ongun has successfully performed numerous endoscopic sinus procedures at Hisar Hospital Intercontinental.

    • 21 years of experience of experience in ENT and head & neck surgery
    • Performs endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS) for nasal polyps
    • Extensive training at Hacettepe University in otology-neurotology and audiology
    • Deputy chief physician with leadership in ENT departments
  • Read more
Package price from$2,500

Harun Dogru

  • 5 Excellent 1 review
  • 29 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Antalya
  • Dr. Harun Dogru has contributed to groundbreaking research on nasal and sinus conditions, including studies on oxidative stress in sinusitis.

    • Published multiple studies on experimental maxillary sinusitis
    • Researched free oxygen radicals' role in otitis media
    • Investigated nitric oxide levels in nasal mucosa
    • Worked at Medical Park Antalya Hospital Complex
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Erkan Vural

  • Leading doctor for Nasal polyp surgery
  • 24 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Prof. Vural specializes in preventing recurrent nasal polyps, with research published in Ther Adv Respir Dis. He leads the ENT department at University of Avrasya.

    • 24 years of experience of experience in otorhinolaryngology
    • Published thesis on nasal polyp prevention
    • Member of Turkish Association of Rhinology
    • Performs endoscopic sinus surgery
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Bora Basaran

  • 5 Excellent 1 review
  • 22 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr. Bora Basaran specializes in endoscopic sinus surgery and nasal polyp treatment at Istanbul Florence Nightingale Hospital.

    • Associate Professor of Otolaryngology with 22 years of experience of experience
    • Fellow of the European Board of Otorhinolaryngology
    • Expert in functional and aesthetic nasal diseases
    • Member of European Head and Neck Society
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Edal Sakli

  • 23 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr. Sakli specializes in rhinoplasty, bringing years of focused expertise to nasal polyp surgeries at Valued Med Hub Hospitals.

    • Associate Professor with extensive training in otorhinolaryngology
    • Member of Turkish Ear Nose Throat Foundation and Facial Plastic Surgery Association
    • Special interest in rhinoplasty, enhancing both function and aesthetics
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Mazhar Celikoyar

  • 41 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Specializes in nasal polyp surgery with extensive experience at Istanbul Florence Nightingale Hospital. Trained in France under leading ENT specialists.

    • 41 years of experience of experience in ENT surgery
    • Trained at Institut Gustave Roussy and Hopital Foch in France
    • Previously served as ENT Chief Assistant at Şişli Etfal Hospital
    • Board-certified in ear, nose, and throat surgery
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Ozcan Oztrk

  • 30 years of experience
  • accreditations:
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Dr. Ozcan Oztrk specializes in nasal polyp surgery with extensive research and international training in ENT procedures.

    • Member of the European Laryngological Society and European Academy of Otology-Neurootology
    • Conducted research on laryngopharyngeal reflux and its impact on ENT health
    • Presented multiple papers at national scientific meetings on ENT diseases
    • Trained at the University of Pittsburgh Sound Center and Gruppo Otologico in Italy
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

Onur Buyukkoc

  • 24 years of experience
  • Location: Turkey, Istanbul
  • Specializes in nasal and sinus conditions at Atlas University Hospital, with extensive training and practice in ENT surgery.

    • Over 24 years of experience of ENT experience across prestigious institutions
    • Published multiple studies on nasal and sinus conditions
    • Trained at Istanbul Okmeydanı Eğt. And Research Hospital
    • Member of Turkish Otolaryngology community with active research contributions
  • Read more
Doctor's visit
Price on request

You've viewed 20 of 53 doctors

Choosing a clinic abroad can be stressful. At Bookimed, with over 800K patients helped, we understand your concerns. We know how to find trusted doctors, the best price-quality options, and solutions for even complex cases. We’re here to guide you every step of the way.

Yan Matsiivskiy

Head of Medical Coordinator Team

4300++ patient journeys guided

3 years at Bookimed

278 patients from Turkey have found their doctor through us this month

How you'll get your perfect doctor match

1

2 min Quiz

Tell us your goal, budget, timeline

2

Human Matching + AI

Our algorithm finds matches, coordinator verifies fit

3

Your Options Ready

Compare prices, packages, dates. Chat with your coordinator

Overwhelmed by choices?

Your personal Bookimed coordinator helps you find the perfect surgeon tailored to your needs

  • Supports you 24/7 at every stage
  • Helps match you with the doctor and handles all communication with clinics
  • Coordinates your travel, accommodation, and transfers

Guiding your treatment

Medically trained personal coordinators

Peguy Beaugris
Tetyana Hyrych
Zekra Eldeeb
Victoria Olayinka
Iryna Sydorchuk
Tetiana Ihnatiuk

Choosing the Right Doctor and Clinic: Insider Tips

When selecting a doctor or clinic, keep these key points in mind:
Check credentials
Verify certifications from bodies like ISAPS, JCI, or relevant medical boards
Review success rates
Choose doctors with solid experience and a proven track record in your specific treatment.
Read patient reviews
Browse Bookimed reviews from real patients to learn about their experiences.
Ensure effective communication
Pick clinics that offer language support for a smooth treatment process.
Ask about services
Confirm whether the price includes services such as accommodation, local transfers, and follow-up care to avoid hidden costs.

Bookimed Insights: Top Nasal polyp surgery Specialists in Turkey (2026)

Bookimed has coordinated 8 requests for Nasal polyp surgery in Turkey, collaborating with 53 top-rated specialists. The doctors in this table are selected based on their international credentials, clinical expertise, and patient outcomes. The 2026 ranking is formed using verified data from actual patient cases and current programs from our partner clinics.
RankDoctorexperienceGood Fit ForWhat Sets Them ApartClinic & LocationConsultation
#120 years of experienceComplex nasal polyp casesSpecializes in endoscopic sinus surgery with advanced academic training. Associate Professor with expertise in complex nasal procedures at Hisar Hospital.
Turkey
from $180
#236 years of experienceComplex nasal polyp casesSpecializes in rhinology with advanced training in Germany. Head of ENT at Anadolu Medical Center. Published extensively on ENT disorders.
Turkey
from $145
#323 years of experienceComplex nasal polyp casesAdvanced European-trained specialist with unique expertise from top international ENT hospitals, including London's Royal National ENT.
Turkey
Price on request
#410 years of experienceEndoscopic sinus surgerySpecializes in nasal polyp surgery with endoscopic techniques. Member of Turkish Facial Plastic Surgery Association, ensuring high standards of care.
Turkey
Price on request
#517 years of experienceAesthetic nasal polyp surgeryInternational training in reconstructive techniques at top global institutes. Active EURAPS member with a focus on aesthetic-functional balance in nasal surgeries.
Turkey
Price on request
#69 years of experienceNasal polyp surgerySpecializes in ENT surgeries with advanced rhinoplasty skills. PhD in ENT from Bezmialem Vakıf University. Focuses on precise surgical techniques and patient-centered care.
Turkey
Price on request
#714 years of experienceNasal polyp removalSpecializes in ENT surgery with decades of experience. Has worked at leading Turkish hospitals including Acibadem Altunizade.
Turkey
Price on request
#830 years of experienceFunctional Endoscopic Sinus SurgerySpecializes in FESS – precise removal of polyps with endoscopic techniques. Head of ENT at a major Turkish hospital with rhinology focus.
Turkey
Price on request
#930 years of experienceComplex nasal polyp casesAdvanced training at House Ear Institute – specializes in complex nasal and sinus conditions. Published 30+ articles and recognized for surgical excellence.
Turkey
Price on request
#1030 years of experienceComplex sinus and nasal conditionsAdvanced training at House Ear Institute in Los Angeles. Published over 30 scientific articles on ENT topics, including sinus conditions. Recognized for excellence in clinical practice.
Turkey
Price on request

FAQ

These FAQs come from real patients seeking medical assistance through Bookimed. Answers are given by experienced medical coordinators and trusted clinic representatives.

How can I tell if a Turkish ENT surgeon is truly experienced in nasal polyp surgery?

Identify experienced Turkish ENT surgeons by prioritizing their medical subspecialty in rhinology over cosmetic services. Truly qualified specialists hold Turkish or European Board certifications and focus on functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS). Experts like Dr. Selman Sarica have performed 1,000+ complex nasal procedures using advanced endoscopic techniques.

  • Board certification: Look for Turkish Society of Otorhinolaryngology or European Board (FEBORL-HNS) credentials.
  • Rhinology membership: Skilled surgeons typically belong to the Turkish Rhinology Society or European Rhinology Association.
  • Surgical volume: Leading specialists like Dr. Abdulkadir Ozgur have performed over 1,000 endoscopic operations.
  • Academic title: Professors and Associate Professors often lead clinical research and handle complex revision cases.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that top-tier Turkish ENT specialists often hold dual roles in academic and clinical settings. For instance, Dr. Arzu Oz operates at both Asyaesthetic Clinic and the JCI-accredited Acibadem Altunizade Hospital. This overlap means surgeons maintain academic rigor while using the latest hospital technologies like 3D navigation for safer sinus clearance.

Patient Consensus: Patients note that reliable surgeons talk openly about long-term recurrence risks and management plans. They appreciate when doctors explain CT findings in detail rather than making vague promises about permanent cures. Many felt more confident when their surgeon discussed coordinating with allergy specialists for comprehensive post-operative care.

Which credentials should I check when choosing a nasal polyp surgeon in Turkey?

When choosing a nasal polyp surgeon in Turkey, verify they are a certified Otorhinolaryngology specialist. Look for Turkish ENT Board certification and advanced training in Functional Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (FESS). Top surgeons often hold European Board (FEBORL-HNS) credentials and work in JCI-accredited hospitals.

  • Board certification: Qualified surgeons must be certified by the Turkish Society of Otorhinolaryngology.
  • FESS expertise: Ensure the doctor specializes in endoscopic techniques used for nasal polyp removal.
  • European fellowships: Look for Fellow of the European Board (FEBORL-HNS) designations for international standards.
  • Academic titles: Titles like Professor or Associate Professor indicate extensive surgical and clinical experience.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows top Turkish ENT specialists often bridge clinical work with academic research. Dr. Celil Göcer and Dr. Mehmet Palali highlight this trend through their published studies. Choosing a surgeon who actively researches nasal polyposis helps ensure they use modern, evidence-based surgical techniques.

Patient Consensus: Patients emphasize that this surgery is about breathing better, not just aesthetics. Many note that a good surgeon provides a clear plan for post-operative care. They feel more confident when doctors explain how to manage long-term recovery and recurrence.

What questions should I ask at the first consultation with a nasal polyp surgeon in Turkey?

When meeting a nasal polyp surgeon in Turkey, ask about their board certification and experience with endoscopic sinus surgery (ESS). Inquire about the specific technique used, such as microdebrider or image-guided navigation. Successful outcomes depend on addressing root causes like allergies or chronic sinusitis.

  • Surgical technique: Ask if they perform functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS) or standard polypectomy.
  • Recurrence prevention: Discuss long-term management plans, including steroid rinses or biologics to prevent regrowth.
  • Experience level: Confirm how many endoscopic procedures they perform annually to ensure high technical proficiency.
  • Pathology protocols: Ensure all removed tissue is sent for analysis to confirm the diagnosis.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that many top Turkish ENT specialists, such as Dr. Selman Sarica or Dr. Celil Göçer, hold teaching titles like Associate Professor or Professor. Patients should look for surgeons with international training at institutions such as the House Ear Institute or Ohio State University. These academic backgrounds often correlate with expertise in complex cases that require combined functional and aesthetic nasal work.

Patient Consensus: Patients often note that understanding whether a blockage is from polyps or a deviated septum is a vital first step. Many were surprised to find that ongoing saline rinses are just as important as the surgery itself. They emphasize confirming that follow-up cleaning visits are included in the travel schedule.

How do Turkish nasal polyp surgeons charge for surgery?

Turkish nasal polyp surgeons typically utilize all-inclusive package pricing for international patients. These bundles cover the surgical procedure, anesthesia, hospital stays, and local transfers. Fees vary based on surgical complexity and the surgeon's academic rank. Standard surgery starts from $2,000 to $3,200.

  • Package inclusions: Bundles usually cover preoperative tests, airport pickups, and hotel accommodations.
  • Surgeon expertise: Fees often reflect academic titles like Professor or Associate Professor.
  • Facility standards: Prices vary between boutique clinics and JCI-accredited hospitals like Hisar Hospital.
  • Additional procedures: Combining polyp removal with septoplasty increases the total package cost.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that choosing an Associate Professor or Professor often adds minimal cost while providing significant academic expertise. For example, Dr. Selman Sarica at Hisar Hospital offers consultations for $180. Patients can access high-level care from specialists with international training in the US or Italy while saving 81% compared to US averages.

Patient Consensus: Patients note that getting a single bundled quote makes planning the trip much easier. Many suggest confirming if follow-up medications and sinus scans are included to avoid extra costs. They often find that paying in cash can sometimes result in better final rates.

Do Turkish surgeons guarantee results or revisions if nasal polyps grow back?

Turkish surgeons do not offer formal guarantees against nasal polyp regrowth because recurrence is biological. Success depends on managing underlying inflammation rather than surgery alone. Reputable specialists provide clear revision policies. These often include reduced surgical fees if polyps return within a specific timeframe.

  • Surgical expertise: Professors use Functional Endoscopic Sinus Surgery (FESS) to minimize tissue trauma.
  • Academic credentials: Many surgeons hold European Board of Otorhinolaryngology (EBOPRAS) certifications for quality.
  • Revision policies: Clinics typically offer discounted rates for secondary procedures if polyps reappear.
  • Long-term care: Doctors focus on post-operative medication and cleaning to prevent future recurrence.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that top Turkish ENT specialists often hold dual roles as researchers. Dr. Mehmet Palali has published studies on the genetic factors of nasal polyposis. Dr. Caglar Calli has over 80 international publications. Choosing a surgeon who actively researches inflammatory triggers can help in creating a more effective long-term prevention plan.

Patient Consensus: Patients note that trustworthy surgeons are honest about high recurrence rates upfront. They suggest checking if revision policies cover hospital and anesthesia fees or just the surgeon's fee. Many were surprised that post-operative nasal cleaning was more vital than the surgery itself.

How can I verify patient feedback and results for Turkish nasal polyp surgeons?

Verifying results for Turkish nasal polyp surgeons requires auditing clinical credentials and functional outcomes. Look for Turkish Board-certified otorhinolaryngologists with academic titles. Reliable data includes endoscopic images and long-term recurrence rates. Bookimed manages credential verification and coordinates logistics for international patients.

  • Academic titles: Professors and Associate Professors often lead specialized ENT departments at accredited hospitals.
  • Board certifications: Qualified surgeons hold Turkish Society of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery (TKBBV) certification.
  • International training: Top doctors often complete fellowships at institutions like the House Ear Institute.
  • Ministry authorization: Clinics must hold an International Health Tourism Authorization Certificate for patient safety.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that choosing an Associate Professor or Professor significantly increases access to academic research. For example, Dr. Celil Göçer at Lokman Hekim Akay Hospital has published 30+ scientific articles. Dr. Selman Sarica at Hisar Hospital Intercontinental holds an Associate Professorship focused on complex endoscopic surgery. These academic leaders typically handle revision cases that require deeper anatomical knowledge.

Patient Consensus: Patients emphasize looking for detailed timelines of breathing improvements and sense of smell recovery. They note that authentic feedback often discusses the management of post-operative inflammation and steroid use. Many suggest focusing on functional airflow rather than hospital luxury when reading about surgical outcomes.

Which cities in Turkey host the highest concentration of expert nasal-polyp surgeons?

Istanbul features the highest concentration of nasal polyp surgeons in Turkey, followed by Ankara and İzmir. These cities host professors and specialists who utilize functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS). Most experts hold board certifications and have trained at leading university hospitals or international medical institutes.

  • Istanbul hub: Most specialists practice here, often holding associate professor or professor titles.
  • Ankara expertise: The capital offers academic-focused care at hospitals like Private Koru Ankara Hospital.
  • İzmir centers: Cities like İzmir host specialized clinics such as ENTO Surgical Medical Center.
  • Accredited facilities: Top surgeons operate at JCI-accredited hospitals like Hisar Hospital Intercontinental and Medipol.

Bookimed Expert Insight: Data shows that İzmir is a unique hub for allergy-related nasal polyps. Surgeons like Dr. Burak Kocagozoglu at Can Hospitals Turkey combine ENT expertise with European Academy of Allergology and Clinical Immunology memberships. This specific specialization is vital for patients whose polyps are triggered by chronic allergic reactions rather than structural issues alone.

Patient Consensus: Patients note that choosing a surgeon in a major city provides easier access to large university-associated hospitals. They often prioritize doctors with a background in complex endoscopic sinus surgery. Many found that established specialists in Istanbul and İzmir provided detailed clarity during consultations.