Medical disclaimer

Pronator Quadratus Release in Scaphoid Nonunion Graft Surgery: Study Summary

In this retrospective study of 37 patients, wrist extension after surgery was significantly greater in the group that had a pronator quadratus (PQ) release than in the group that did not, while the difference in failed unions was not significant. Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital in Istanbul appears only as the author affiliation, and the abstract does not say where the patients were treated.

8 min read

Prepared by Bookimed editorial team

Medical content and care coordination

Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital
← All research summaries
Published research, not an individual patient story.

The named clinic is an author affiliation. The study patients were not established as patients treated at that clinic.

Key takeaways

  • The study reviewed 37 patients with scaphoid nonunion (a broken wrist bone that did not heal) who had a pronator quadratus pedicled bone graft (PQPBG).
  • 17 patients had the PQ ulnar origin released and 20 did not.
  • Mean wrist extension after surgery was 43.5 with release and 36.5 without release (p = 0.0038).
  • Failures were one patient with release and four without, and this difference was not statistically significant (p = 0.11).
  • The authors conclude that PQPBG is a viable option for bone union but restricts wrist extension after surgery.

The question this study addresses

Authors including a doctor from the Orthopedic and Traumatology Clinic of Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital reviewed patients with scaphoid nonunion who had a PQPBG between 2009 and 2020. They split the patients by whether the PQ ulnar origin was released to help the graft reach further. They compared wrist motion, grip strength, two outcome scores and failure rates. The abstract does not say where the patients were treated, so this page does not describe them as patients of the clinic.

The situation
Scaphoid nonunion, a broken wrist bone that has not healed, in 37 patients.
The treatment
Surgery with a pronator quadratus pedicled bone graft (a bone graft from the forearm that keeps its own blood supply), with or without release of the PQ ulnar origin.

What this evidence cannot establish

  • The abstract does not say where the patients were treated. Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital appears as an author affiliation only.
  • This is a retrospective review, so the groups were not assigned at random, and the abstract does not state follow-up length or the units of wrist extension.
  • The study is small, and group results are not a forecast for any individual reader.

Patient groups in the published study

17 patients · Published study group

Graft surgery with PQ origin release

Indication
Scaphoid nonunion
Treatment
Pronator quadratus pedicled bone graft (PQPBG) with release of the PQ ulnar origin

17 patients with scaphoid nonunion

Scaphoid nonunion treated with a PQPBG in which the PQ ulnar origin was released to improve how far the graft could be moved.

PQPBG with PQ ulnar origin release. The mean wrist extension after surgery in this group was 43.5 (units not stated).

  • Postoperative mean wrist extension (mean)

    43.5 ± 6.8 not stated

    17 patients · Study group

    Plus/minus as reported by the source

    not stated

Reported risks

  • Study-wide items only: the authors report that the PQPBG technique restricts wrist extension after surgery. Failures were one patient in this group.

Limits of this evidence

  • Follow-up duration, units of wrist extension and union rate are not stated in the abstract.
  • The two groups were compared in a retrospective review, not a randomized trial.

For a clinic assessment

  • Wrist imaging reports and the surgical history for the scaphoid nonunion
  • Any previous operative notes and recent wrist range of motion measurements

20 patients · Published study group

Graft surgery without PQ origin release

Indication
Scaphoid nonunion
Treatment
Pronator quadratus pedicled bone graft (PQPBG) without release of the PQ ulnar origin

20 patients with scaphoid nonunion

Scaphoid nonunion treated with a PQPBG in which the PQ ulnar origin was left in place.

PQPBG without PQ origin release. The mean wrist extension after surgery in this group was 36.5 (units not stated).

  • Postoperative mean wrist extension (mean)

    36.5 ± 7.7 not stated

    20 patients · Study group

    Plus/minus as reported by the source

    not stated

Reported risks

  • Study-wide items only: the authors report that the PQPBG technique restricts wrist extension after surgery. Failures were four patients in this group.

Limits of this evidence

  • Follow-up duration, units of wrist extension and union rate are not stated in the abstract.
  • The difference in failures between the groups was not statistically significant (p = 0.11).

For a clinic assessment

  • Wrist imaging reports and the history of earlier treatment of the scaphoid
  • Notes on current wrist motion and grip strength, if measured

Results and limits of the study

Mean wrist extension after surgery was significantly greater with PQ release (43.5 ± 6.8) than without (36.5 ± 7.7), p = 0.0038. Wrist flexion, ulnar deviation, radial deviation, outcome scores and grip strength were greater with release, but the differences were not statistically significant (p > 0.05). Failures were one patient with release and four without (p = 0.11). The authors say PQ release may have a favorable effect on bone union and clinical outcomes.

Risks reported by the source

  • The authors report that the PQPBG technique restricts wrist extension after surgery.
  • Graft failure occurred in one patient in the release group and four in the group without release.

Limitations and unknowns

  • How long the patients were followed after surgery is not stated.
  • The units of wrist extension and the overall union rate are not stated.
  • Where the patients were treated is not stated.
  • Whether these results apply to a particular reader is unknown, because group results are not a forecast for an individual.

What to clarify in your treatment plan

Before booking, ask the clinic which surgeon would assess your wrist and whether they use the PQPBG technique, and ask what the clinic would need to review your case. Ask what imaging and records they want in advance, and how follow-up visits would be arranged. Ask the clinic to explain in writing how it would plan your care.

Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital: clinic profile

  • Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital appears in this study as an author affiliation: the authors list its Orthopedic and Traumatology Clinic. The abstract does not say where the patients were treated.
  • The clinic profile is available on Bookimed under Bone Fracture Treatment in Istanbul, Turkey.
Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital

Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital

Istanbul, Turkey

4.6/5 · 165 Bookimed reviews (current clinic profile)

Mustafa Kurklu: doctor profile

Mustafa Kurklu

Mustafa Kurklu

Orthopedic surgeon

23 years of experience

Safety and recovery: general information

General patient guidance, provided separately from the case evidence. Follow your treating team's instructions.

Possible side effects

  • Stiffness in the wrist can occur after wrist injuries and treatment.

    Ask the surgeon what motion to expect and how stiffness is managed.

  • Severe pain that does not get better may be a sign of complex regional pain syndrome.

    Report ongoing severe pain to your doctor promptly.

  • Opioid pain medicines can help with severe pain but may be addictive and can be dangerous.

    Discuss pain control options with your doctor before surgery.

Recovery and aftercare

  • For distal radius fractures, a source from the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons says use for all activities can take about 3 months and full recovery can take up to 1 year. This is general wrist fracture information, not a result of this study.

    Ask your surgeon for a recovery timeline for your own case.

  • A cast or splint may be worn for several weeks, depending on the type of fracture and which bone is affected.

    Ask how long immobilization is expected in your plan.

Suitability and cautions

  • The choice of treatment can depend on the type of fracture, your age and activity level, and your surgeon's judgment.

    Have a surgeon assess whether a given technique fits your situation.

  • A small group of patients may be too sick to safely have surgery.

    Share your full medical history with the clinic.

When to contact the clinic

  • Severe pain that does not get better or gets worse, or new weakness or trouble bending your thumb or index finger, may need emergency care.

    Go to an emergency room right away.

  • A very painful injury, a wrist that looks badly bent or out of place, or numb or pale fingers may need urgent care.

    Go straight to an urgent care center or emergency room.

  • Not being able to fully move your fingers within 24 hours because of pain or swelling should be reported.

    Tell your doctor.

Request a personal plan from the clinic

Ask Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital about assessment for scaphoid nonunion and wrist fracture care

Send your wrist imaging and medical history through the Bookimed coordinator. The coordinator passes them to the clinic and asks whether a surgeon can review your case.

Ask the clinic for a current, itemized quotation. Published evidence does not establish package inclusions or a current price.

Frequently asked questions

Who ran this study and where were the patients treated?

The study was written by authors who list the Orthopedic and Traumatology Clinic of Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital in Istanbul as their affiliation. The abstract does not say where the patients were treated, so this page does not say they were treated at the hospital. Bookimed did not run the study. It summarizes the published abstract only.

Did PQ release improve results in scaphoid nonunion surgery?

Wrist extension was significantly greater with PQ release. The mean was 43.5 with release and 36.5 without, p = 0.0038. Failures were one patient with release and four without, which was not a significant difference (p = 0.11). Other measures were greater with release but not significantly. The authors say release may have a favorable effect, which is not a promise for any reader.

Does the PQPBG technique limit wrist movement?

Yes, according to the authors. They conclude that the technique is a viable option for bone union in scaphoid nonunion but results in restricted wrist extension after surgery. The group with PQ release had greater mean wrist extension than the group without. The abstract does not give units or follow-up time, so ask your surgeon what to expect.

How many patients were in the study?

The study included 37 patients with scaphoid nonunion treated with PQPBG between 2009 and 2020. Of these, 17 had the PQ ulnar origin released and 20 did not. The abstract does not state how long the patients were followed. Because the study is a retrospective review, the groups were not assigned at random.

Sources and scope

This page was prepared from the published abstract of the study and a checked table of its reported numbers. Safety information comes from the quoted medical sources, not from the study.

  1. 1. Heydar et al. – The Impact of Pronator Quadratus Origin Release on the Clinical Outcomes of Scaphoid Nonunion Patients Treated with Pronator Quadratus Pedicled Bone Grafts.

    Retrospective review comparing PQ release versus no release · 2024

    37 patients with scaphoid nonunion treated with a pronator quadratus pedicled bone graft, 2009-2020

    Follow-up: Not stated in the abstract

    Only the abstract was used, so details on follow-up, units and the treatment setting are missing.

  2. 2. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (OrthoInfo)
  3. 3. American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (OrthoInfo)
  4. 4. MedlinePlus (U.S. National Library of Medicine)
  5. 5. Memorial Bahçelievler Hospital on Bookimed
  6. 6. Mustafa Kurklu on Bookimed

Scope and limitations

  • A research summary is not an individual medical recommendation.
  • Group results describe the study participants, not a forecast for any one patient.

Related procedures

About the editorial team

Bookimed editorial team

Prepared by

Bookimed editorial team

Medical content and care coordination

Bookimed prepares evidence summaries from published medical sources and anonymized care records. The clinic and any doctors named on this page are identified separately in their own sections.

About this page

This page summarizes cited evidence and links to current Bookimed provider profiles. It does not replace an individual diagnosis or treatment plan. Published group results are not a guarantee of your outcome.

Clinic profiles and package availability come from the current Site catalog. Historical costs and research measurements keep their original context.

Report a correction