Medical disclaimer
Bone-Preserving vs Radical Surgery for Chronic Heel Bone Infection: Research by Carolina Hospital's Doctors
8 min read
Prepared by Bookimed editorial team
Medical content and care coordination
The named clinic is an author affiliation. The study patients were not established as patients treated at that clinic.
Key takeaways
- The series included 32 adults with chronic calcaneal osteomyelitis: 8 superficial, 12 localised and 12 diffuse by the Cierny-Mader classification.
- Healing of infection and wound was reported after 7 of 9 debridements, 6 of 8 drilling operations and 13 of 15 partial calcanectomies, and after all total calcanectomies.
- The authors report inferior infection control with bone-preserving operations (76,47% vs 88,24%) and worse patient satisfaction (88,24% vs 100%), with almost comparable ambulation (100% vs 93,33%).
- The authors suggest drilling of the heel bone with a gentamicin collagen sponge seems a viable alternative in diffuse disease.
- This is a single-department case series with level of evidence V, so group results are not a forecast for any individual patient.
The question this study addresses
Surgeons at the Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Medical University of Warsaw, compared bone-preserving and radical operations for chronic heel bone infection. The aim was to heal infection, keep the heel shape and achieve good skin coverage over the heel bone. The patients were treated at the university department, not at Carolina Hospital. Dr. Ireneusz Babiak is listed as an author of the paper and, according to the Bookimed profile, now practices at Carolina Hospital in Warsaw.
- The situation
- Adults with chronic osteomyelitis (bone infection) of the calcaneus (heel bone): 8 superficial, 12 localised and 12 diffuse type.
- The treatment
- Surgery of different extent: debridement with or without flaps, drilling of the heel bone with a collagen-gentamicin sponge in the bore holes, partial or total calcanectomy (removal of part or all of the heel bone) and below-the-knee amputation.
What this evidence cannot establish
- The patients were treated at the Medical University of Warsaw, not at Carolina Hospital, so the results describe that department's series and not Carolina Hospital's own patients.
- The abstract does not state follow-up time or complications, and the groups are small.
- It is a single-department case series (level of evidence V), without a randomized comparison.
Patient groups in the published study
9 procedures · Published study group
Debridement, with or without flaps
- Indication
- Chronic calcaneal osteomyelitis
- Treatment
- Debridement surgery with or without flaps
Adults with chronic heel bone infection; 9 debridement procedures were reported.
Chronic infection of the heel bone treated by cleaning out infected tissue, sometimes with a flap to cover the wound.
Debridement surgery with or without flaps. Infection and wound healing was achieved after 7 of 9 procedures.
Infection and wound healed after debridement
7 / 9
9 procedures · Study group
not stated
Reported risks
- Study-wide: the abstract does not state complications for this or any other group.
Limits of this evidence
- Follow-up duration and complications for this group are not stated.
- The abstract counts procedures, not separate patients.
For a clinic assessment
- Imaging reports and the infection type, if known
- Previous surgery and wound care records
8 procedures · Published study group
Drilling of the heel bone with a gentamicin collagen sponge
- Indication
- Chronic calcaneal osteomyelitis
- Treatment
- Drilling of the calcaneus with collagen-gentamicin sponge in bore holes
Adults with chronic heel bone infection; 8 drilling operations were reported.
Chronic infection of the heel bone, including diffuse disease, where the authors wanted to keep the heel bone.
Holes were drilled in the heel bone and a collagen sponge with the antibiotic gentamicin was placed in them. Infection and wound healing was achieved after 6 of 8 operations.
Infection and wound healed after drilling
6 / 8
8 procedures · Study group
not stated
Reported risks
- Study-wide: the abstract does not state complications for this or any other group.
Limits of this evidence
- Follow-up duration and complications for this group are not stated.
- The authors describe the alternative as one that seems viable, which is not proof of equal results.
For a clinic assessment
- Imaging reports showing the extent of infection
- Antibiotic history and any allergy information
15 procedures · Published study group
Partial removal of the heel bone
- Indication
- Chronic calcaneal osteomyelitis
- Treatment
- Partial calcanectomy
Adults with chronic heel bone infection; 15 partial calcanectomies were reported.
Chronic infection of the heel bone treated by removing the infected part of the bone.
Partial calcanectomy. Infection and wound healing was achieved after 13 of 15 operations.
Infection and wound healed after partial calcanectomy
13 / 15
15 procedures · Study group
not stated
Reported risks
- Study-wide: the abstract does not state complications for this or any other group.
Limits of this evidence
- Follow-up duration and complications for this group are not stated.
- The abstract counts procedures, not separate patients.
For a clinic assessment
- Imaging reports and operative notes from earlier surgery
- Records of walking ability before treatment
Results and limits of the study
Healing of infection and wound was reported after 7 of 9 debridements, 6 of 8 drilling operations, 13 of 15 partial calcanectomies and all total calcanectomies. The authors conclude that bone-preserving operations gave inferior infection control (76,47% vs 88,24%) and worse patient satisfaction (88,24% vs 100%), with almost comparable ambulation (100% vs 93,33%). They suggest that drilling with a gentamicin collagen sponge seems to be a viable alternative to partial or radical calcanectomy in chronic diffuse disease. These are group results and not a forecast for the reader.
Risks reported by the source
- The abstract does not report adverse events or complications for any group.
Limitations and unknowns
- How long patients were followed after surgery.
- Complications and repeat operations in each group.
- Which patients were chosen for which operation, and why.
- Healing results after below-the-knee amputation.
What to clarify in your treatment plan
Before booking, ask Carolina Hospital whether it treats chronic heel bone infection and which operations it offers. Clarify which records the surgeon needs to review your case, who would be your treating doctor, and how follow-up care would be arranged. Ask the coordinator to confirm in writing what the clinic can and cannot offer.
Carolina Hospital: clinic profile
- The study patients were treated at the Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Medical University of Warsaw, and not at Carolina Hospital.
- All authors are affiliated with the Medical University of Warsaw, and none lists Carolina Hospital.
- The Carolina Hospital profile in Warsaw is available on Bookimed.
The current provider profile is temporarily unavailable. The published evidence on this page remains available.
Ireneusz Babiak: doctor profile
- Ireneusz Babiak is listed as an author of the paper, with an affiliation at the Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Medical University of Warsaw.
- He is an orthopaedist whose profile fits a paper on bone infection, and according to the Bookimed profile he now practices at Carolina Hospital.
The current provider profile is temporarily unavailable. The published evidence on this page remains available.
Safety and recovery: general information
General patient guidance, provided separately from the case evidence. Follow your treating team's instructions.
Possible side effects
- Short-term complications of surgery can include reactions to anesthesia, bleeding, blood clots, pain and infections.
Ask the surgeon which of these apply to your operation and how they are monitored.
Recovery and aftercare
- Most patients may notice improvement in strength, function and mobility for 1 to 2 years after surgery, with little additional improvement after that, according to a general orthopaedic source.
Ask the clinic what recovery and rehabilitation to expect in your case.
Suitability and cautions
- People in poor health, for example with heart, liver or kidney problems, might not be able to withstand the stress of anesthesia and surgery.
Share your full medical history with the coordinator so the surgeon can assess this.
When to contact the clinic
- After surgery, pain, bleeding or signs of infection can occur as short-term complications.
Contact the clinic promptly if you notice these after an operation.
Request a personal plan from the clinic
Ask Carolina Hospital about its evaluation and treatment options for chronic heel bone infection
Send your imaging and medical records to the Bookimed coordinator, who passes them to Carolina Hospital. The clinic then tells you whether it can assess your case and what it would need.
Ask the clinic for a current, itemized quotation. Published evidence does not establish package inclusions or a current price.
Frequently asked questions
Who ran this study and where were the patients treated?
The study was run by authors from the Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Medical University of Warsaw, where the patients were treated. They were not treated at Carolina Hospital, and none of the authors lists Carolina Hospital as an affiliation. Ireneusz Babiak is an author and, according to the Bookimed profile, now practices at Carolina Hospital. Bookimed did not run or fund the study; this page summarizes the published abstract.
Does bone-preserving surgery work as well as radical surgery for heel bone infection?
In this series, bone-preserving operations gave inferior infection control than radical ones (76,47% vs 88,24%) and worse patient satisfaction (88,24% vs 100%), with almost comparable ambulation (100% vs 93,33%). The authors note that radical procedures can be functionally disabling. The groups were small and follow-up is not stated, so these results do not predict what would happen in your case.
What is drilling of the heel bone with a gentamicin collagen sponge?
It is an operation in which holes are drilled in the infected heel bone and a collagen sponge containing the antibiotic gentamicin is placed in them. In the series, infection and wound healing was achieved after 6 of 8 drilling operations. The authors say it seems to offer a viable alternative to partial or radical calcanectomy in chronic diffuse disease. Whether it suits you is a question for your surgeon.
Can I be sure of the same results at Carolina Hospital?
No. The results come from patients treated at the Medical University of Warsaw, not at Carolina Hospital, and they describe a small group, not an individual forecast. Outcomes depend on the extent of infection, your health and the chosen operation. Ask the clinic through the Bookimed coordinator what it can offer in your situation and what information the surgeon needs to assess your case.
Sources and scope
This page was prepared from the published abstract of the study, its extracted numbers checked against the abstract, and general medical sources for safety information. Bookimed did not run the study.
- 1. Babiak et al. – Comparison of Bone Preserving and Radical Surgical Treatment in 32 Cases of Calcaneal Osteomyelitis.
Single-department case series, bone-preserving vs radical surgery · 2016
32 adults with chronic calcaneal osteomyelitis: 8 superficial, 12 localised and 12 diffuse type.
Follow-up: Not stated in the abstract
Only the abstract was used, and it does not state follow-up time, complications or how patients were assigned to each operation.
- 2. American Cancer Society
- 3. AAOS OrthoInfo
- 4. Carolina Hospital on Bookimed
- 5. Ireneusz Babiak on Bookimed
Scope and limitations
- A research summary is not an individual medical recommendation.
- Group results describe the study participants, not a forecast for any one patient.
About the editorial team

Prepared by
Bookimed editorial teamMedical content and care coordination
Bookimed prepares evidence summaries from published medical sources and anonymized care records. The clinic and any doctors named on this page are identified separately in their own sections.