Medical disclaimer

TUIP or Silodosin for Small Prostate: Retrograde Ejaculation Compared

In this study of 192 men with a small prostate and fertility concerns, retrograde ejaculation was reported in 11 of 96 men after transurethral incision of the prostate (TUIP) and in 33 of 96 men taking silodosin. The patients were treated at the Department of Urology of Hisar Intercontinental Hospital in Istanbul, which is the same hospital as Hisar Hospital Intercontinental, listed on Bookimed.

8 min read

Prepared by Bookimed editorial team

Medical content and care coordination

Hisar Hospital Intercontinental
← All research summaries
Published research, not an individual patient story.

The source identifies treatment at the named clinic. Study results describe this cohort, not a predicted individual outcome.

Key takeaways

  • The study compared TUIP with silodosin 8 mg in 192 men who had urinary symptoms from a prostate smaller than 40 ml and fertility concerns.
  • At 12 months, retrograde ejaculation (semen flowing back into the bladder) was reported in 11 of 96 men after TUIP and 33 of 96 men on silodosin.
  • Both treatments improved urine flow, symptom score and residual urine, and the improvement in symptom score and flow was larger after TUIP.
  • The authors concluded that TUIP may be a better choice for younger men who want to preserve ejaculation.
  • These are group results from one center and are not a forecast for any individual patient.

The question this study addresses

Doctors at Hisar Intercontinental Hospital in Istanbul reviewed data collected prospectively from December 2011 through December 2014. They compared two ways of treating bladder outlet obstruction (a blocked urine flow) caused by a small prostate: a surgical incision (TUIP) or a daily tablet (silodosin 8 mg). The patients were treated at this hospital, which is the same hospital as Hisar Hospital Intercontinental under a slightly different name. The main focus was retrograde ejaculation (RE), alongside symptom score (IPSS), maximal urine flow rate (Qmax) and postvoiding residual urine (PVR).

The situation
Men with lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) from bladder outlet obstruction, a prostate smaller than 40 ml and fertility concerns.
The treatment
Transurethral incision of the prostate (TUIP) in 96 men, or continuous silodosin 8 mg in 96 men, with results checked at 12 months.

What this evidence cannot establish

  • The abstract describes a single-center series and does not give the actual IPSS, Qmax or PVR values.
  • The patients were treated at the same hospital whose doctors ran the study, so the study was not independent of the clinic.
  • Bookimed did not run the study, and the abstract alone cannot show how any one man would respond.

Patient groups in the published study

96 patients · Published study group

Small prostate treated with TUIP

Indication
Bladder outlet obstruction with urinary symptoms, prostate volume smaller than 40 ml, fertility concerns
Treatment
Transurethral incision of the prostate (TUIP)

96 men with a small prostate and fertility concerns

Men with urinary symptoms from a small prostate who were concerned about fertility and chose or were assigned surgery.

TUIP, a procedure that makes a small cut in the prostate to ease urine flow. Results were checked at 12 months.

  • Retrograde ejaculation

    11 / 96

    96 patients · Study group

    12 months

Reported risks

  • Study-wide item: retrograde ejaculation was reported in 11 of 96 men after TUIP at 12 months.

Limits of this evidence

  • The abstract does not give the actual IPSS, Qmax or PVR values for this group.

For a clinic assessment

  • Recent urology reports, including prostate size measurements and any urine flow test results
  • A list of current medicines and any earlier prostate treatment

96 patients · Published study group

Small prostate treated with silodosin

Indication
Bladder outlet obstruction with urinary symptoms, prostate volume smaller than 40 ml, fertility concerns
Treatment
Silodosin 8 mg continuous treatment

96 men with a small prostate and fertility concerns

Men with urinary symptoms from a small prostate who were concerned about fertility and took a daily tablet instead of surgery.

Silodosin 8 mg taken continuously. Results were checked at 12 months.

  • Retrograde ejaculation

    33 / 96

    96 patients · Study group

    12 months

Reported risks

  • Study-wide item: retrograde ejaculation was reported in 33 of 96 men on silodosin at 12 months.

Limits of this evidence

  • The abstract does not give the actual IPSS, Qmax or PVR values for this group.

For a clinic assessment

  • Recent urology reports and any current prescription for silodosin or similar medicines
  • A note of any ejaculation changes you have already noticed

Results and limits of the study

At 12 months, both groups improved in symptom score (IPSS), maximal flow rate (Qmax) and postvoiding residual urine (PVR). The improvement in IPSS and Qmax was larger in the TUIP group. Retrograde ejaculation was reported in 11 of 96 men after TUIP and 33 of 96 men on silodosin. The authors suggest TUIP is a better choice for younger men who want to preserve ejaculation.

Risks reported by the source

  • Retrograde ejaculation was reported in 11 of 96 men after TUIP and in 33 of 96 men on silodosin at 12 months.

Limitations and unknowns

  • The abstract does not give the actual IPSS, Qmax or PVR values.
  • It does not say how men were assigned to TUIP or silodosin.
  • It does not report other adverse events or the need for repeat treatment.
  • Results beyond 12 months are not described.

What to clarify in your treatment plan

Before booking, ask the clinic which assessments it needs from you, such as prostate size and urine flow tests. Ask how ejaculation and fertility plans are discussed before treatment, and who would perform and follow up your care. Also ask what the coordinator needs from you to arrange a consultation and how follow-up is handled when you travel.

Hisar Hospital Intercontinental: clinic profile

  • The study patients were treated at Hisar Intercontinental Hospital in Istanbul, which is the same hospital as Hisar Hospital Intercontinental.
  • The study authors list the hospital's Department of Urology as their affiliation.
  • The clinic profile is available on Bookimed.
Hisar Hospital Intercontinental

Hisar Hospital Intercontinental

Istanbul, Turkey

4.5/5 · 266 Bookimed reviews (current clinic profile)

Basri Cakiroglu: doctor profile

  • Basri Cakiroglu is the first author of the study and lists the Department of Urology at Hisar Intercontinental Hospital as his affiliation.
Basri Cakiroglu

Basri Cakiroglu

Pediatric urologist, Urological surgeon, Urologist

32 years of experience

Safety and recovery: general information

General patient guidance, provided separately from the case evidence. Follow your treating team's instructions.

Possible side effects

  • TUIP may cause retrograde ejaculation, erectile dysfunction, urinary tract infections, scar tissue in the bladder neck, urinary incontinence or a narrowed urethra.

    Ask the surgeon how likely each of these is for you and how they are managed.

  • People who have TUIP may be more likely to need another surgery within a few years than people who have TURP.

    Ask what follow-up and repeat treatment could involve.

Recovery and aftercare

  • Full recovery from TUIP can take three to five weeks, and symptom improvement may not be noticed for a few weeks or months.

    Plan your travel and time off with the clinic's guidance.

Suitability and cautions

  • TUIP is used for a moderately enlarged prostate that blocks the flow of urine, so it may not suit every man.

    Ask the urologist whether your prostate size and symptoms fit this procedure.

  • TUIP may be considered when side effects that affect fertility are a concern, or when other treatments are less suitable because of other health conditions.

    Discuss your fertility plans and health history with the urologist.

  • Another procedure may sometimes be offered instead, and each option may not be suitable for everyone.

    Ask which alternatives were considered for you.

When to contact the clinic

  • Contact your care team right away if you have fever, cloudy or foul-smelling urine, unexpected or severe pain, or a lot of blood in your urine.

    Keep the clinic's contact details with you after treatment.

  • Seek urgent medical help if you have blood in your urine, pain when urinating, or cannot urinate at all.

    If you are abroad, ask the clinic how to reach the team and local services.

Request a personal plan from the clinic

Ask Hisar Hospital Intercontinental about TUIP for a small prostate

Send your urology reports to the Bookimed coordinator, who passes them to the clinic. The clinic then tells you whether a consultation about TUIP can be arranged.

Ask the clinic for a current, itemized quotation. Published evidence does not establish package inclusions or a current price.

Frequently asked questions

Who ran this study and where were the patients treated?

The study was run by doctors from the Department of Urology at Hisar Intercontinental Hospital in Istanbul, and the patients were treated there. This is the same hospital as Hisar Hospital Intercontinental on Bookimed, listed under a slightly different name. The first author, Basri Cakiroglu, lists this hospital as his affiliation. Bookimed did not run the study and only summarizes its published abstract.

Did TUIP or silodosin cause less retrograde ejaculation?

TUIP was linked to less retrograde ejaculation in this study. At 12 months, it was reported in 11 of 96 men after TUIP and 33 of 96 men on silodosin. Retrograde ejaculation means semen flows back into the bladder. These are group results from one center and do not predict what would happen to you.

Did both treatments help urinary symptoms?

Yes, both treatments helped according to the abstract. At 12 months, symptom score (IPSS) and postvoiding residual urine (PVR) decreased and maximal flow rate (Qmax) improved in both groups. The improvement in IPSS and Qmax was larger in the TUIP group. The abstract does not give the actual values, so the size of the change is not known.

Who might TUIP be considered for?

The authors suggest TUIP may be a better choice for younger men with fertility concerns who want to preserve ejaculation and have a prostate smaller than 40 ml. Whether it suits you depends on your own health and prostate size. A urologist needs to assess that, so ask the clinic about your situation before deciding.

Sources and scope

This page was prepared from the published abstract of the study and the structured numbers taken from it. Safety information comes from named medical sources and is separate from the study results.

  1. 1. Cakiroglu et al. – Comparison of transurethral incision of the prostate and silodosin in patients having benign prostatic obstruction in terms of retrograde ejaculation.

    Prospective single-center comparison of TUIP and silodosin · 2017

    192 men with urinary symptoms, a prostate smaller than 40 ml and fertility concerns

    Follow-up: 12 months

    Only the abstract was used, so study methods, actual measurements and other adverse events are not described here.

  2. 2. Cleveland Clinic
  3. 3. NHS
  4. 4. Hisar Hospital Intercontinental on Bookimed
  5. 5. Basri Cakiroglu on Bookimed

Scope and limitations

  • A research summary is not an individual medical recommendation.
  • Group results describe the study participants, not a forecast for any one patient.

Related procedures

About the editorial team

Bookimed editorial team

Prepared by

Bookimed editorial team

Medical content and care coordination

Bookimed prepares evidence summaries from published medical sources and anonymized care records. The clinic and any doctors named on this page are identified separately in their own sections.

About this page

This page summarizes cited evidence and links to current Bookimed provider profiles. It does not replace an individual diagnosis or treatment plan. Published group results are not a guarantee of your outcome.

Clinic profiles and package availability come from the current Site catalog. Historical costs and research measurements keep their original context.

Report a correction