Is Stem Cell Therapy Legal in the US? A Comparative Guide to Global Regulations

Stem cell therapy is one of the most promising advancements in modern medicine. It is being hailed for its ability to regenerate tissues, reduce inflammation, and tackle medical conditions that were once thought untreatable. 

But as exciting as it sounds, navigating the legal status—especially in the US—can be tricky. Patients are often left wondering whether these breakthrough treatments are even allowed. In this article, we’ll untangle US regulations and look at other countries where you can find safe, legal stem cell treatments.

Table of Contents

1. Are Stem Cells Legal in the US?
2. Where Is Stem Cell Therapy Legal?
3. Protecting Yourself: Ethical and Safety Considerations for Patients
4. How to Choose a Reliable and Safe Stem Cell Clinic
5. Key Takeaways

Are Stem Cells Legal in the US?

Short answer: Partly. Only certain stem cell therapies, like those for blood disorders, are FDA-approved and legal. Most treatments haven’t yet passed the necessary approval process.

FDA’s role in stem cell regulation

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates the safety and effectiveness of medical treatments, including stem cell therapies. Stem cell treatments must undergo clinical trials and receive FDA approval to be legal. This ensures they meet safety and efficacy standards before being offered to the general public.

What are the FDA-approved stem cell therapies?

Currently, the only FDA-approved stem cell treatment in the US is hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). This therapy uses stem cells from umbilical cord blood to treat certain cancers and disorders affecting the blood and immune system, such as leukemia.

Still, there’s a lot of hope on the horizon. Although the FDA hasn’t greenlighted many stem cell treatments for general use, they do approve a significant number of clinical trials. In fact, over 5,000 registered clinical trials in the US are currently gathering proof of stem cell therapy’s safety and effectiveness. Clinical trials are a critical step in expanding the approved uses of stem cells in medicine.

Limitations of stem cell therapy in the US

Despite FDA regulations, almost 3,000 clinics in the US offer unproven therapies for a wide range of medical conditions. These clinics try to bypass FDA regulations by:

• Labeling treatments as “experimental”. Some clinics market their stem cell treatments as part of ongoing stem cell research. However, it may lack proper oversight or adherence to safety protocols.
• Using patient-funded trials. Some clinics offer treatments through so-called clinical trials where patients pay for the therapy, blurring the line between research and commercial services. 
• Operating under state-level laws. Some clinics take advantage of less stringent state regulations, allowing them to offer treatments that wouldn’t pass under federal FDA guidelines.
• Offering reduced dosages. Some clinics use reduced dosages of stem cells to circumvent FDA regulations, claiming their treatments are not technically “stem cell products.”

While these methods enable clinics to offer unapproved stem cell treatments, choosing one of these clinics may come with real risks. Here’s why:

• Safety concerns. A key issue with unapproved stem cell therapies is the lack of quality control. Without FDA oversight, there is no guarantee that the stem cells are being correctly handled and processed. Some stem cell clinics may use stem cells from unproven sources, which could be less effective or even harmful.
• Ineffective dosages. Some clinics lower the amount of stem cells used in treatments to avoid FDA oversight. However, research shows that higher dosages often produce better results. Reduced doses may not be effective enough to repair or regenerate damaged tissue properly.

Stem cell research and clinical trials in the US

The lack of FDA approval for stem cell treatments doesn’t mean they’re not considered effective by U.S. scientists. In fact, numerous FDA-approved clinical trials have shown that stem cell therapies are safe and effective in multiple application areas, such as orthopedic, neurological, and heart conditions. 

However, FDA approval is required to ensure that stem cell treatments in the US undergo rigorous testing before being marketed. This ensures that the therapies meet safety standards, are properly regulated, and provide reliable outcomes for patients.

Where Is Stem Cell Therapy Legal?

Stem cell therapy is gaining traction worldwide, but the legal landscape varies significantly from one country to another. While the US has strict regulations, some nations have embraced stem cell treatments more fully. Here’s a quick overview of the most prominent destinations for legal stem cell therapy:

North and South America

✈️ Mexico

Mexico’s regulatory framework for stem cell therapies is more flexible than in the US. It allows stem cell clinics to offer treatments that are still in clinical trials elsewhere. The Federal Commission for Protection against Sanitary Risks (COFEPRIS) allows treatments in regenerative medicine, including orthopedic and neurological conditions. 

However, obtaining a COFEPRIS license for stem cell therapy takes work. The clinic must provide extensive documentation to prove its safety and compliance with regulations regarding the facility, equipment, procedures, and medical staff training.

To conduct stem cell therapy, clinics need to obtain specific licenses, such as:

• Stem Cell Collection License (for harvesting cells mesenchymal stem cells);
• Surgery Room License (for performing procedures);
• Regenerative Medicine License (to legally offer stem cell treatments).

These licenses ensure clinics meet strict standards for safety, equipment, and medical expertise.

The Bookimed team has compared over 150 stem cell clinics worldwide according to the Ranking Policy. This policy takes into account the clinic’s accreditations, reputation, patient demand, and feedback. As a result, we have identified the top clinics in Mexico offering COFEPRIS-approved stem cell therapies:

✈️ Colombia

Colombia’s National Institute of Food and Drug Monitoring (INVIMA) governs the regulation of stem cell therapies. Several laws and decrees ensure that stem cell collection, storage, and clinical use meet high safety and ethical standards. Before conducting any treatment, clinics should rigorously test stem cells for diseases and disease agents.

Middle East

✈️ Turkey

Stem cell therapy in Turkey is regulated by the Turkish Ministry of Health. Additionally, the Turkish Academy of Sciences and TÜBA Stem Cell Work Group support stem cell research in the country. The group also organizes conferences, symposiums, and research projects to foster collaboration between national and international scientists.

Check out Turkey’s leading clinics licensed to provide stem cell therapies by the Ministry of Health:

✈️ Israel

Israel is a pioneer in stem cell research, with the Ministry of Health ensuring strict oversight of stem cell therapies. 

Israeli scientists played a pivotal role in developing CRISPR gene-editing technology, which can help create universal stem cell treatments without the risk of immune rejection.

✈️ Netherlands

In the Netherlands, stem cell research and treatments are regulated by the Dutch Healthcare Inspectorate and the Dutch Central Committee on Research Involving Human Subjects (CCMO). They allow only treatments that are proven safe. Therapies are closely monitored under clinical trial conditions. Most recently, the Dutch government approved stem cell treatment for multiple sclerosis (MS).

The country has a robust scientific community actively involved in stem cell research. In 2022, researchers from Leiden University Medical Center (LUMC) successfully used stem cell gene therapy to treat a baby with severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID)—the first successful case of its kind in history.

✈️ Switzerland

In Switzerland, stem cell therapies are tightly regulated by Swissmedic, the national regulatory body for therapeutic products. Stem cell treatments must comply with the Transplantation Act and the Therapeutic Products Act.

Clinics offering stem cell treatments in Switzerland must hold an establishment license from Swissmedic. It ensures strict adherence to legal and medical standards.

✈️ Poland

Stem cell treatments are legal in Poland. They are regulated directly by the Ministry of Health. The country is also home to the Polish Stem Cell Bank PBKM, the head of Europe's largest network of stem cells.

Here are Poland’s most trusted stem cell clinics:

✈️ Ukraine

Ukraine has emerged as a hub for affordable and innovative stem cell treatments, with fewer regulatory hurdles than in other European countries. The Ukrainian Ministry of Health regulates treatments, stem cell products, and clinical trials. All medical staff and clinics involved in stem cell therapies must comply with the regulations developed by the Ministry.

Ukrainian clinics offer therapies that are still in trial stages in other countries. For instance, Ukraine is the only country that offers legal and regulated fetal stem cell therapy. It is home to the world’s first fully licensed fetal stem cell bank, owned by the EmCell Therapy Center. 

Here are the most prominent clinics in Ukraine offering licensed stem cell therapies:

Asia

✈️ Thailand

In Thailand, the Thai Food and Drug Administration (Thai FDA) regulates stem cell therapies. Doctors must obtain scientific and ethical approval from the Medical Council to provide stem cell therapies. 

The focus areas of stem cell research and application in Thailand include:

• treatments for diabetes;
• peripheral vascular disease;
• coronary artery disease;
• ischemic stroke;
• spinal cord injuries;
• amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS);
• traumatic brain injuries.

Explore the best clinics in Thailand offering TFDA-regulated stem cell treatments:

✈️ South Korea

South Korea offers numerous stem cell treatments approved by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety (MFDS). The Ministry of Health provides targeted funding to boost research in both rare diseases (such as spinal cord injuries) and common chronic conditions like arthritis.

South Korea is a leader in regenerative medicine, with the second-highest number of approvals for stem cell therapies worldwide. Its expedited approval process helps bring innovative treatments to market more quickly. Meanwhile, the process ensures patient safety through required long-term follow-ups. 

For world-class stem cell treatments, explore South Korea’s top clinics:

Protecting Yourself: Ethical and Safety Considerations for Patients

Stem cell therapy is still a developing field, so it’s essential to be extra cautious and well-informed. Here are some critical points to keep in mind when considering stem cell treatment:

1. Consider ethical implications

Not all types of stem cells are viewed the same in terms of ethics. One of the most debated areas is the use of stem cells from human embryos, typically left over from in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatments. Since obtaining these cells destroys the embryo, this raises ethical concerns.

On the other hand, some argue that since these embryos would otherwise be discarded, using them for medical purposes serves the greater good. You need to decide where you stand on this issue and be aware of what stem cells your treatment will involve.

2. Consult a licensed medical professional first

Always consult a licensed and qualified doctor before considering any stem cell therapy. If you’re unsure where to start, Bookimed can connect you with reputable specialists and clinics worldwide for a free consultation.

3. Understand the regulations in the chosen country

Various countries have different regulations surrounding stem cell therapy. Make sure the country you're considering has a strong regulatory framework in place to protect patients and ensure treatments are scientifically validated.

4. Ensure scientific validation 

Make sure stem cell therapy for your condition is backed by peer-reviewed research and has been validated in clinical trials. You can check clinical trial data on platforms like ClinicalTrials.gov or search for published research on sites like PubMed. These platforms provide data on ongoing and completed stem cell research.

5. Beware of misleading claims

Be cautious of clinics promising miracle cures or claiming treatments for unapproved uses. Stem cell therapies are still experimental treatments for many conditions, so verify whether the therapy is part of a legitimate clinical trial or simply unproven.

6. Understand potential complications

Although clinical trials indicate the relative safety of stem cell treatments, there can still be side effects depending on the type of stem cells and the treated condition. Ask your doctor about the short- and long-term risks of the specific treatment you are considering.

7. Don’t rush your decision—consider all alternatives

Take your time to evaluate whether stem cell therapy is the best course of action for you. Be cautious of any pressure to make quick decisions or commit to immediate treatment without exploring other options.

How to Choose a Reliable and Safe Stem Cell Clinic

With various clinics and treatments available worldwide, here are key steps to help you make informed decisions about your health:

1. Research the clinic’s credentials and certifications for stem cell therapy

Ensure that the stem cell clinic complies with regulatory standards in the country, such as those set by the FDA in the U.S. or equivalent organizations elsewhere. Accredited clinics provide scientifically backed, safe treatments.

2. Verify safety protocols

Make sure the clinic follows strict safety protocols for handling, processing, and administering stem cells. Compliance with guidelines reduces risks such as contamination or infections.

3. Read reviews and patient testimonials

Investigate reviews from past patients and ask the clinic’s representatives for success stories. A clinic with a solid reputation will have a history of positive patient experiences that can provide you with a clearer picture of its reliability.

4. Check for informed consent procedures

A reputable healthcare provider will fully inform you about the risks, benefits, and alternative treatments before undergoing therapy. You should never feel rushed into a decision. Avoid clinics that skim over the risks or pressure you to sign paperwork without proper consultation.

5. Ask about post-treatment monitoring and follow-up care

Ethical providers will offer ongoing care after the procedure to monitor for potential side effects or complications. This reflects a commitment to patient well-being beyond just the treatment itself.

6. Look for transparency in pricing and treatment plans

Reliable clinics are upfront about the costs involved. They should offer clear, detailed treatment plans after evaluating your case. There should be no hidden fees or surprise charges after you begin treatment.

7. Avoid clinics that promise miraculous results

Be cautious of language that promises complete recovery or miracle cures without scientific evidence. Reputable providers set realistic expectations and make it clear that results may vary.

Key Takeaways

👉 Stem cell therapy legality in the US. Only hematopoietic stem cell transplantation for blood disorders is FDA-approved and legal. 

👉 Limitations in the US. Many US clinics offer unproven therapies by bypassing FDA regulations. Without FDA approval, these therapies can pose safety risks due to improper handling.

👉 Global options for stem cell therapy. Mexico, Colombia, Turkey, Thailand, South Korea, Israel, Germany, Netherlands, Poland, Switzerland, and Ukraine offer stem cell therapies that are approved and regulated by FDA-equivalent bodies in these countries. These therapies are monitored for safety and effectiveness under stringent national standards.

👉 Ethical and safety considerations. Before seeking treatment, research stem cell types and available research regarding your condition. Make sure to consult a licensed doctor and learn about the benefits and risks associated with the treatment.

👉 Choosing a reliable clinic. Ensure the clinic is licensed by relevant regulatory bodies (e.g., COFEPRIS, INVIMA, Swissmedic) to perform stem cell therapies. Look for clinics with clear pricing, positive patient reviews, and post-treatment follow-up care to ensure your safety and well-being. Bookimed can connect you to accredited clinics worldwide.

Related Articles

1. How Much Does Stem Cell Therapy Cost in 2024?
2. Where to Get Stem Cell Therapy: TOP 10 Countries